Target Talk

High-end Air Pistols Comparison - Yet Another Viewpoint

Posted by Alexey on July 31, 2001 at 01:51:06:
Hi, everybody,
I live in Russia and I'm going to buy a high-end air pistol. There are no dealers to order a gun from, and trained gunsmiths are to be found in Moscow or perhaps even in Helsinki. Since the performance of all the modern high-end pistols is actually so good that you can discuss it at indefinite lengths and still end up nowhere, the only reasonable criterion of my choice is obvious - it should never, ever crap out. So: Is there among them a model which is definitely more reliable and maintenance-free than all the others?
Best regards, Alexey.

Posted by Joseph Tousignant on July 31, 2001 at 03:18:48:
Hi Alexey, boy, you're asking the impossible here! EVERY pistol will need servicing and maintenance on a regular schedule. Pneumatic pistols have seals that will need replacing, same with CO2 and PCP pistols. True enough different models more often than others. Some have said the seals can go bad if "dirt" gets into them from careless handling of tank connections and so forth. You're "never, ever crap out" criteria is therefore not an absolutely attainable goal! An interesting question is are there "scuba" type tanks and supplies available if you choose a pre-charged pneumatic? (Or a bulk supply of CO2, for that matter?) You could bypass the tanks with a pump, of course, but at some point the pump itself will need servicing also, though most will last a long time from what I’ve heard.
If these necessary supplies and maintenance items would be a problem attaining on a regular basis, then i would recommend the pistol I’ve chosen for it's very long track record of reliable service and low maintenance. Most reading my posts are already aware of it, the Feinwerkbau 65 Mkll (FWB)
Nothing else to buy except pellets and a very infrequent drop or two of a quality chamber lube such as "Beeman's" Ultra Lube. After a lot (several years sometimes)of shooting a breach seal might need replacing, but it is user serviceable and inexpensive(at least in the US). Everything else about the gun has proven itself reliable, with the additional benefit of being quite familiar to most airgunsmiths should anything else need servicing. As the "spring-piston" design of this pistol has a steel sealing ring over the piston (much like a car engine), it will last a very long time. If not stored "cocked" for extended periods of time the mainsprings will also hold up quite well. No reason you couldn't shoot this pistol several years without a whimper out of it! Getting an extra breach seal ahead of time, and possibly a set of mainsprings (the FWB 65 Mkll and the one inch or so longer barreled FWB 65 Mkl both use 2 concentric springs) would go a long way into insuring the most probable area of future part needs would be met.
They can cost, in the US, anywhere from $300-about $600 used. (only available "used" now as FWB had discontinued production in 1998, and any "new" ones are basically older stock). It will take you a very long way to becoming a respectable pistol shooter, but may not be available to you there. I also have no idea what they might cost in your part of the world.
Anyway, good luck in your search!
Joseph Tousignant

Posted by william on July 31, 2001 at 08:22:05:
Good morning, Alexey! Are you not able to find the Izh-46 anywhere in Moscow? They are built a thousand kilometers East of you. You will be hard pressed to find anybody who has had a problem with one - I have had mine for 6 years. It comes with all the spare parts needed for a lifetime's shooting, and just about everything is user replaceable. No tanks, no pumps, no adaptors! Good luck

Posted by Joseph Tousignant on July 31, 2001 at 10:58:30:
Just as a follow-up...I was going to mention the IZH 46 (or even newer IZH 4M), but Alexey had stated he was looking for a "High End" match pistol. No disrespect intended here, but i saw one at the recent air gun show (Baldwinsville, N.Y.) and was not personally impressed by the esthetics of its construction. (The sample there, while new in a box, appeared like it might leave "slivers" if someone were to use it as the wood parts were not fully sanded and finished). Most posts I’ve read about it say it shoots pretty good, and is a good value for the money...but a "high end " gun it is not! One poster even talked about the barrel being off-center on his, so i can't believe the quality control is up to, say, German manufacturing standards. I also assumed Alexey KNEW about the pistol available from his homeland, and had passed on acquiring one. Anyway, hope he finds a pistol he can be happy with.
Joseph Tousignant

Posted by carl on July 31, 2001 at 09:52:51:
Hey Alexey,
Welcome to the sport. I think you’ll find air pistol to be quite challenging and fun. As far as reliability I haven’t heard of anybody having trouble with any of the high end air pistols. Except for a few of the early SAM K-11's. My steir LP-10 has been perfect after 7000 rounds. Any machine can break down. One option is to federal express the pistol to Warren here at pilkguns. He is one of the gunsmiths for our Olympic team and a very nice guy also. I don’t know about Russia but here in the US an air pistol is not classed as a firearm so there isn’t any regulations on shiping it. So, Id go for it and get one of the high end guns like the steir. The baikal is a good entry level gun but it’s not as fast and easy to shoot at the other high end guns. If you know anybody in Russia its best to try them all before you buy. However you cant really go wrong with any of them. Remember the most important part of any pistol is the grip holding nut. You’ll do fine. I knew some Russian guys in college. Smart and hard working people. Take care, Carl

Return to the Previous Page

Sponsored by Pilkington Competition Equipment